Are Your Case Studies Actually Turning Away Prospects?

Are Your Case Studies Actually Turning Away Prospects?

Are Your Case Studies Actually Turning Away Prospects?

By John Jantsch

case study format

Case Study Format

I’m a big fan of case studies as an important part of the content journey.

The reason a well-crafted case study can be so effective is that if you strip away all the marketing talk and focus on telling the story of a real business getting real results you’ve got the makings of a pretty potent marketing asset.

People love to see people in their same situation getting a result they too would love to get by way of working with you.

How a case can study hurt more than help

The key to writing an effective case study lies in throwing out the template used by 99% of marketers.

You’ve seen it a million times – Client situation, client challenge, our solution, their results, more about us.

Now, sometimes this format serves well, but here’s where it might turn away people you were meant to serve.

The traditional format assumes that the reader has the same problem or challenge or at least framed it that way, and it assumes they are ready to accept the same solution.

The truth is that they probably don’t know what their real challenge is and by sharing your solution they can either get someone else to do it or dismiss it without enough information to make an intelligent decision.

And that’s how your case studies are costing you big.

Focus on not solving the problem

A more useful approach is to spell out how much not solving their problem could eventually cost. This, by the way, is the most efficient way to sell in person as well.

You have to get your prospect invested in finding some solution at any cost because not doing so could lead to eventual doom.

I’m not trying to suggest too much drama here, but when I sell marketing consulting services people often start by suggesting they need more leads. Simple enough until you can get them to further investigate what would happen if they didn’t.

Maybe they lose their job or their house. Or maybe they just miss out on other parts of their life.
This isn’t an appeal to sell fear; it’s an appeal to dig deep enough so that your prospects know how much they have to gain by solving all of their problems.

Wrap it all up in potential value

When you help people better understand the gravity of their challenges, you can more easily get them to invest in a world where all of their problems go away.

You can help them see any solution you recommend as an investment rather than a cost and when you sell services, in particular, this is a must.

So now your case study format may look more like this: Situation, overarching challenge, the cost of not finding a solution, results gained by the solution we implemented.

In this format you’ve juxtaposed pain and gain and did you notice – nowhere did you reveal how you got the result – that’s the discussion for your proposal!

The other thing that this format does is that it creates a great desire to solve problems while giving you tremendous leeway to address just how you can solve the problems.

Instead of telling your prospect what their problem is and how to solve you get them involved in defining and communicating the story of their problem, so you let them feel like the solution is of their own design.

Recently, I interviewed Ian Altman, author of Same Side Selling, a book that also recommends this very practical approach for both case studies and selling in general.

Free eBook 
7 Steps to Scale Your Consulting Practice Without Adding Overhead

"This training from Duct Tape Marketing has exceeded my expectations and I couldn't be happier" ~ Brooke Patterson, VanderMedia

The Ultimate Guide to Finding and Hiring a World-Class Marketing Manager
When you first start your business, you’re wearing every hat—you’re overseeing every single aspect of the company: Accounting, check.  Sales outreach, add it to your to-do list. Administrative work, it’s not going to do itself. And let’s not forget, you’re the full-time Marketing director, too. Your list of roles and responsibilities goes on. And these […]
7 Small Business Trends that Arrived Just in Time for 2021
This blog post is brought to you by GoDaddy Pro. Every year for the last 20 or so, I’ve wrapped up the year with my predictions for trends in the coming year. I’m usually spot on too. But that’s really more of a testament to the fact that trends tend to creep up on us […]

Subscribe to the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast

If you know your small business needs marketing, but don’t have the time or resources, look no further. The Duct Tape Marketing podcast covers everything from earning referrals to managing time and being more productive.

Get the 7 Step guide to growing your small business

In the 7 Steps to small business marketing success you'll learn:

  • Why strategy must come before tactics
  • Why and what customers really buy
  • How to make Google your new best friend
  • How to install an integrated marketing system

Or simply text the word DUCTTAPE to 66866