Cathryn Sloan and Why Social Media Experts Have Such Low Self-Esteem

Cathryn Sloan and Why Social Media Experts Have Such Low Self-Esteem

Cathryn Sloan and Why Social Media Experts Have Such Low Self-Esteem

By John Jantsch

Last week a recent University of Iowa grad and, to this point, unknown journalist named Cathryn Sloan penned an article for the nextgen Journal titled Why Every Social Media Manager Should Be Under 25.

The firestorm the article created was something to behold and while I do believe that Sloan’s greatest mistake was that she wrote a piece that seemed a bit oblivious to the fact that the whole world, and not just her age peers, would read it, I watched in horror at the way the piece incited the social media world over twenty five to react. (598 comments at this writing)

The piece went viral because social media forty somethings disagreed violently with her point. Had it stayed there, however, I wouldn’t be writing this post. I saw a number of tweets regarding the piece and curiosity drove me to read it. Like many, I didn’t agree with her point of view nor how she was trying make her point, but I admired that she had a point of view.

As I started to read the comments and reactions I was moved firmly into to her camp as a supporter and even reached out to offer to do an interview to help her tell her story. The rage, hatred, insults and mocking that came through in several hundred comments, including some from very well known names in the bright lights of social media, was one of the most disgusting displays of insensitivity and rudeness I think I’ve witnessed in a long time and it made me very sad to play in this space.

Any argument that the dissenting side was trying to make couldn’t be considered seriously. Yes, there were exceptions, but the overall tone exposed many of the over twenty-five social media set as little more than wannabes lacking enough self-esteem in their own value to take a shot from someone clearly trying to find a voice in a very tough place.

To borrow from Shakespeare – “Me thinks you doth protest too much.” So, let me ask you this – what are you really afraid of?

Some further chided her for not responding to the storm and while that would the obvious route, the social media clan made it next to impossible for her to respond in the manner they deserved.

To me, many of the crybabies and downright haters helped her make her point. I know that it’s really easy to pick on someone you don’t know via comments in a blog post, but if there’s anything my generation is charged with passing to the next it’s common decency and manners and I just hope we haven’t lost track of what those things are.

There, I feel a lot better now.


The Mildly Inauthentic Nature of Social Media
I wrote a bit of an off the cuff post on Facebook yesterday that drew far more interaction and conversation than I expected. I think in part because it came dangerously close to defining an uneasy feeling that many people have about sharing in networks like Facebook. They can’t quite put their finger on it, […]
Do You Ever Feel Stuck In Your Business?
I’ve owned my own business for 28 years now and I can tell you that I’ve never quite figured out the delicate balance between me telling want my business what it wants to be and my business telling me what it wants to be, but I have come to recognize that struggle. Last week I […]

Subscribe to the Duct Tape Marketing Podcast

If you know your small business needs marketing, but don’t have the time or resources, look no further. The Duct Tape Marketing podcast covers everything from earning referrals to managing time and being more productive.

Looking to get your business higher search rankings, more exposure, and more leads?  This Local SEO Playbook will help

Focus on these five elements and you can expect great results from local search.

x